Skip to content
  • Home
  • About
  • Services
  • Research
  • News
  • Podcast
  • Contact

Phone: ‪(203) 343-0433‬

Find us on Map
info@thepscgroup.net
The Public Safety Consulting GroupThe Public Safety Consulting Group
The Public Safety Consulting GroupThe Public Safety Consulting Group
  • Home
  • About
  • Services
  • Research
  • News
  • Podcast
  • Contact
Volunteer EMS Transition: How Towns Move to Combination or Career
Paid and volunteer EMS crew at shift handoff

Volunteer EMS Transition: How Towns Move to Combination or Career

November 15, 2026 Posted by PSCG News

A volunteer EMS transition works when it starts before the crisis, is built around the hours your community actually fails to cover, and keeps your volunteers inside the system. The strongest plans begin with data on when calls arrive and when volunteers are available, then add paid staff to cover those gaps only, funded by a realistic mix of local budget and billing revenue. We work alongside municipal leaders on this every day, and we invite you to call us to talk through your own situation.

The Public Safety Consulting Group
thepscgroup.net
Plan a Sustainable EMS Transition
PSCG works with municipal leaders on EMS system design and strategy to help towns plan staffing models around community needs.

Visit

TL;DR

  • Weekday daytime is usually where volunteer coverage fails first, so that is usually where paid crews begin.
  • Transitions can lose most of the volunteers if leaders treat them as a replacement. A combination system keeps both groups on equal standards.
  • Cost is the first hurdle. Paid crews are a constant expense every hour of every day, so funding must be modeled by year before the first hire.
  • Analyze call data, staffing availability and revenue first. Then choose the model.
  • Call us for more information on a staffing analysis for your agency.

Table of Contents

  • Why the transition is happening
  • Signs it is time to plan
  • The staffing models on the table
  • Start small, start where the gap is
  • A seven-part plan
  • Paying for it
  • Keeping your volunteers
  • Our approach to the transition
  • FAQ
  • Sources

Why the transition is happening

The numbers explain the pressure. NAEMT’s 2024 fact sheet reports that about 13% of U.S. EMS professionals are volunteers, that volunteer agencies are most often rural, and that they struggle to recruit and retain. The same fact sheet notes that EMS is funded mainly by local taxes and municipal budgets, together with fee-for-service reimbursement from Medicare, Medicaid and commercial insurers.

Todd Bowman, writing in EMS1 in October 2024, links the shortage to long commutes, multiple jobs and long hours that leave little time for training. Steve Simon of the Western Virginia EMS Council described the shift in Cardinal News as a natural progression: as volunteers decline, local governments staff more hours, until they are staffing a 24-hour ambulance. Weekday working hours are usually where the need for paid crews begins.

None of this is a failure of your volunteers. It is a mismatch between what the job now demands and the hours people have to give.

Signs it is time to plan

James L. Jester, in a Firehouse column from August 2021, names three signals:

  1. Call volume above roughly 750 calls a year, which strains a volunteer EMS system.
  2. Falling volunteer numbers while competition for volunteers grows.
  3. A wider range of call types, which adds training hours for each member.

Treat these as prompts for analysis, not as a formula. Your own data should answer four questions:

  • At what hours do calls go unanswered, delayed or handed to mutual aid?
  • How many certified members are actually available at each hour?
  • How have response times moved over the past three to five years?
  • What are the call-volume trends, and how many calls are transports that can be billed?

Our guide to EMS staffing analysis walks through that work, and our response time analysis article shows how to read the results.

The staffing models on the table

The Kentucky EMS Medical Directors Handbook separates agencies into three types: career, with paid providers and standardizable staffing; volunteer, uncompensated and mostly rural with variable staffing; and combination, a blend whose cost savings depend on a sustainable volunteer pool.

Between those poles sit several practical options:

ModelHow it worksBest fit
Paid-per-call or stipend on-callResponders are paid per response or for scheduled on-call periodsLow call volume, stable volunteer pool
Day-time paid staffOne or two paid providers cover weekday hoursFirst step for most small agencies
Hybrid 24/7 baselinePaid crews cover low-availability hours, volunteers augmentRising volume, thinning volunteer roster
Contract staffingA transport company supplies paid crews under the agency’s licenseFast gap-fill while a long-term plan is built
Full careerPaid staff at all hoursVolume or demand beyond what a blend can handle

The Wisconsin Policy Forum describes paid-per-call, stipend, hourly shift and unpaid volunteer models, often supplemented by one or two full-time staff, and notes that the all-volunteer approach is becoming nearly impossible for a growing number of communities to sustain.

Two real examples show the range. Surry County, Virginia, in a 2018 request for proposals, funded a private transport company to provide paid personnel around the clock to supplement its volunteer rescue squad. Each crew had one ALS and one BLS provider operating under the agency’s license and medical director, and the squad’s 1,100 calls were mostly weekday daytime. Ossining, New York, described a hybrid model in which paid EMTs and paramedics give 24/7 baseline coverage in low-availability hours, volunteers augment staffing and reduce per-call costs, volunteer lieutenants lead operationally, and career supervisors handle quality assurance, training oversight and compliance.

For a deeper comparison, see our overview of EMS staffing models and our guide to EMS deployment models for municipalities.

Start small, start where the gap is

Fire Chief Marc Bashoor, writing in FireRescue1 in February 2024, says there is no cookie-cutter combination department. For a one- or two-station department, the evolution is usually slow, often beginning with a day-time driver at one station. He recommends placing paid staff at higher call-volume locations with lower volunteer participation while continuing to support the remaining volunteer stations.

That principle is the core of peak-load deployment: put resources where and when demand is. Our article on peak demand staffing tactics covers how agencies match crews to demand curves, and System Status Management is the discipline of moving units to match predicted demand rather than fixed posts.

A seven-part plan

Assistant Chief Randall Hanifen of West Chester, Ohio, outlined seven preparation areas for conversion in a 2020 FireRescue1 account of an IAFC session. Applied to EMS, they make a workable checklist:

  1. Collaborate with neighbors. Regional arrangements spread the cost of a force that is on duty every hour.
  2. Know current costs. He notes that about 80% of a budget is tied up in personnel.
  3. Project ten years out. A first-year budget hides the long-term burden.
  4. Map funding mechanisms. City budget, levies, EMS billing and taxes.
  5. Read the politics. Elected officials, volunteers, unions and residents each have a stake.
  6. Plan integration. Shift structure, rank structure and EMS regulatory management.
  7. Write the conversion plan. Personnel, operating and capital costs, year by year.

Hanifen also observed that converting existing volunteers into paid positions makes the change easier, because staff see their own people taking the jobs.

When you build the personnel cost forecast, remember that payroll is not the only line. Employer obligations such as workers’ compensation are part of it, and a workers’ compensation cost calculator can help you see how benefit and rate structures behave when you model new positions.

Paying for it

Paid crews are a constant cost, and a small jurisdiction often cannot carry them alone. Hanifen suggested cross-trained fire/EMS crews on a regional basis as one way to share it. On the revenue side, NAEMT reports that of 42.6 million EMS responses in 2018, only 30.9 million resulted in transports, leaving more than 11 million responses without a transport fee. That is why billing performance matters so much: a transition that adds payroll without improving collections can run into a budget wall quickly.

Before you commit, review your claim process, coding and denial patterns. Our resources on ambulance HCPCS codes and Medicare rules and Medicaid ambulance billing denials show where revenue is commonly lost, and our municipal EMS strategy page describes our reimbursement optimization work.

Keeping your volunteers

Joe Maruca warned in Firehouse in June 2026 that many transitions lose most of their volunteers, leaving a department able to staff one ambulance. His advice: choose the first full-time hires for their ability to help with volunteer recruitment, retention and training, put good systems in place before the first hire, and make sure chief officers are never seen to favor one group.

A USFA applied research paper on retaining volunteers during transition reached similar conclusions: volunteers need to feel regularly valued and not subordinate to career staff, career and volunteer members should be scheduled together, and everyone needs equal access to training and promotion. Bowman’s six standards give you a concrete frame: the same standard of care, education, quality assurance review, response times, minimum staffing and uniformed appearance for both groups.

Virginia’s data show how common the blended path is. The state’s Office of EMS counts 552 licensed agencies: 261 volunteer, 152 career and 139 combination. Reported benefits include improved staffing, more consistent responses, shorter response times and more flexibility. The two big hurdles are funding and friction with existing squads.

Virginia EMS agencies by staffing model

Our approach to the transition

We offer a defined path for agencies and municipalities making this move, drawing on more than 32 years of field experience in public safety. Our work includes High Performance EMS system design, Peak-Load Staffing Modeling and Scheduling, Deployment Plan Design, Response Time Improvement Analysis, Financial Improvement Analysis, and Billing and Collections Process Improvement. We support you from issue identification through deployment.

If you want to see how we have worked with other agencies, visit our work page. When you are ready to talk, contact us, or simply call us for more information.

The Public Safety Consulting Group

Our perspective

A transition is a design problem before it is a hiring problem. Leaders who begin with the question of how many paid positions to create tend to end up in a budget fight. Leaders who begin with when and where the community is underserved end up with a plan the council can fund and the volunteers can join.

We believe the strongest systems keep the volunteer tradition and add the reliability residents now expect. That requires honest data on demand, a staffing model matched to it, and a billing operation that turns the transports you already perform into revenue. It also requires respect: volunteers built your service, and the plan should say so in its structure, not just in speeches.

This is the work we do alongside EMS chiefs, town leaders and dispatch managers. We would be glad to help you build it.

Michael A. Loiz

FAQ

How long does a volunteer EMS transition take?

For a small agency it is usually gradual. Bashoor notes that the move from all-volunteer to combination is often slow, frequently starting with a day-time driver at one station. Many communities add hours in steps as call volume and budget allow.

Where should paid staff go first?

Where volunteer availability is lowest and call volume is highest. Weekday working hours are commonly the first gap, according to Steve Simon’s comments to Cardinal News. Your own call-by-hour data should confirm it.

Do career and volunteer providers have to meet the same standards?

Yes. Bowman recommends one set of standards for both groups, covering standards of care, education, quality review, response times, minimum staffing and appearance. Equal standards also support morale during the change.

How do we fund the added cost?

Most communities combine local tax revenue or levies with transport billing to Medicare, Medicaid and commercial insurers, and some share costs regionally. A year-by-year conversion plan shows the council what each source must cover. Call us for more information on modeling it for your agency.

Sources

  • NAEMT, What is EMS? (2024)
  • EMS1, Flatline to the bottom line
  • Cardinal News, paid EMS services in Virginia
  • Firehouse, Three Signs for When It’s Time to Transition
  • Kentucky EMS Medical Directors Handbook
  • Wisconsin Policy Forum, Henken analysis
  • Surry County, Virginia RFP
  • Ossining EMS Hybrid Model
  • FireRescue1, How to build a combination fire department
  • FireRescue1, volunteer-to-paid conversion
  • Firehouse, Keys to a Volunteer Department Transitioning to Combination
  • USFA, Retaining Volunteers during Transition

Recommended

  • EMS Deployment Models For Municipalities: Choosing The Right Fit
  • How To Launch A Third Service EMS System For Municipalities
  • Municipal EMS Best Practices: Optimize Response And Impact
  • Optimize EMS Response Models For Better Public Safety

Share via:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Related

Tags: 9-1-1911AdvocateambulanceConsultantconsultantsconsultingCT-USexpertLeaderLoizpartnershipsprinciplesPSCGPublic Safety
    0
    Michael A. Loiz, author

    About PSCG

    The Public Safety Consulting Group (PSCG) is a Connecticut-based EMS and public safety consulting firm specializing in EMS system design, municipal EMS strategy, reimbursement optimization, legislative advocacy, leadership development, and operational risk reduction.

    You also might be interested in

    EMS managers reviewing financial data in office

    Enhance EMS financial analysis for sustainable municipal services

    May 2, 2026

    Master EMS financial analysis with our guide. Optimize costs, set reserves, and ensure sustainable municipal services for the future.

    Managers reviewing performance gaps in meeting

    Managers: Close Performance Gaps in One Meeting With a 4 Step Method

    Sep 30, 2026

    A manager first, time boxed method to close performance gaps: name the metric, classify the gap, assign one owner, and run a one meeting four step closure...

    Hands organizing public safety risk reports with PSCG badge visible

    Types of Operational Risks: A Public Safety Leader’s Guide

    Jul 8, 2026

    Explore the types of operational risks in public safety. Understand key categories to strengthen your risk management strategy and enhance safety.

    Recent Posts

    • Ambulance Posting Plans: How EMS Leaders Build Ones That Work
    • 2027 Ambulance Inflation Factor: What the 2.5% Medicare Increase Means for EMS
    • HIPAA Privacy Rule Changes 2027: What EMS Agencies Must Do
    • Volunteer EMS Transition: How Towns Move to Combination or Career
    • Data Retention for EMS: How Long to Keep Records

    Send us your news!

    If you have or know of a story related to PSCG that we have not seen, please feel free to send it to: info@thepscgroup.net so that we can include it here.

    Categories

    • News

    Contact Us

    We're excited that you're interested in PSCG! Let us know how we can help you and someone from our team will get back to you, asap.

    "Redefining Excellence in Public Safety" Contact Us

    Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | FAQ | Research
    131 Morningside Ct. Shelton, CT 06484 USA
    ‪(203) 343-0433‬ | info@thepscgroup.net

    SiteLock

    © 2026 · The Public Safety Consulting Group (PSCG).

    Prev Next
    Manage Cookie Consent
    To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
    Functional Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    • Manage options
    • Manage services
    • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
    • Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    • {title}
    • {title}
    • {title}

    The newsletter

    Get EMS Leadership in your inbox

    Short, practical leadership notes from Michael A. Loiz, plus each new podcast episode as it is released. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    Read past issues on Substack →